
08/08/2025
When Leeds and Liverpool ‘disgraced’ the season curtain-raiser by Jon Howe
This August, Leeds United will be marking their Premier League return with a visit from Everton to Elland Road, but back in 1974 a tumultuous season started with a Charity Shield date at Wembley with the other Merseyside giant, and a suitably chaotic occasion ensued.
As the reigning league title holders Leeds United should have been in a happy place, but were far from it and it showed. As it happens, both Leeds and Liverpool were at remarkably similar junctures in their history and trajectory. Don Revie and Bill Shankly had each taken their clubs from Second Division mediocrity to competing at the top of the European game, but after 13 and 15 years at the helm respectively, the two esteemed managers had vacated the hotseat that summer.
While Liverpool promoted from within in Bob Paisley, Leeds opted not to do likewise with Johnny Giles. Instead, many believe Leeds changed their historic course forever by appointing Brian Clough, and this was his first game in charge. Accordingly, the mood had soured in the Leeds dressing room as the acerbic Clough failed to win over his new squad, and while the Leeds-Liverpool rivalry had been historically competitive, it had never boiled over into outright physical antipathy, until today.
Liverpool took a 20th minute lead in the Wembley sunshine when Phil Boersma bundled in the rebound from a Kevin Keegan shot Leeds goalkeeper David Harvey could only parry. But events erupted in the second half. Spiteful challenges from both sides had littered the play, and Leeds’s playmaker Giles reacted when Keegan raked his shins once again. In full view of the referee Bob Matthewson, Giles floored Keegan with a right hook, but received only a yellow card.
Moments later, in the 60th minute, Keegan swung a punch at Leeds captain Billy Bremner off-the-ball. He later said it was in retaliation to Bremner punching him initially. Regardless, the ref had had enough and sent both players off. Keegan lost his rag, took off his shirt and threw it away. Several yards behind him, Bremner did the same as they each took the long trudge back to the dressing rooms.
Leeds equalised on 70 minutes with a deft Trevor Cherry header from a deep Peter Lorimer cross, but lost the game on penalties – the first time the Charity Shield had been settled that way - when goalkeeper Harvey skied a sudden death spot kick. To widespread incredulity, the FA continued their summer ‘get tough’ campaign to clean-up the game, and awarded both Keegan and Bremner with unprecedented 11-match bans for bringing the game into disrepute.