05/04/2026
Preservation Month: Day 3
Yesterday's Preservation Month post was about what happens when a community comes together to save its history. Today is about what happens when it doesn’t.
For generations, the “old rec gym”, or the “red barn gym” as it was even often called, was more than just a building. It was where basketball games were played and basketball practices were held for decades. Where Union County youth learned the basics and fundamentals of the game of basketball and got their "first taste" of competition. Where square dances were held. Where donkey ball brought people together with laughter and humor. Where proms, gatherings, and even pageants were held. And where many Sorghum Festival parades began. It was a place where memories were made.
And just beside that gym sat the first consolidated Union County High School, and later the Mountain Education Center. That’s where thousands of students shared lunches, learned life lessons, learned their basic skills needed in life, built friendships, earned their high school diplomas, and grew up together. For many, it’s where their story in Union County truly began.
In addition, it was also believed to be the 2nd oldest standing gym in Northeast Georgia(This includes the counties of Union, Banks, Dawson, Fannin, Gilmer, Habersham, Lumpkin, Pickens, Rabun, Stephens, Towns, and White Counties) behind Tate Gymnasium, which still stands today at 100 years old and has been repurposed as an event center. To see more of what happens at this very gym in Tate, we encourage you to check out this link: https://pickensprogress.com/100-year-old-historic-tate-gym-headlines-saturdays-tate-day/
But sadly today, these historical Union County buildings and treasures are gone. Torn down less than a year ago. Replaced with something new. Something "needed". Something practical. New baseball and softball fields.
And to be fair, there were reasons, just like there were reasons to just go ahead and tear down the historical courthouse many years ago. The buildings were aging. There were concerns about structural issues. There were even talks of deterioration and potential hazards. At the same time, the county is growing. Space is limited. And opportunities, like the availability of dirt from the Highway 515 expansion, don’t come around often.
So a decision was made. But here’s the question that will always linger: Was there another way where preservation and modernization could have co-existed?
Because sometimes, preservation isn’t just about saving a building as-is. It’s about reimagining what it could become. There was a vision to see that gym repurposed(Don't believe it? Check the screenshot from the Gooch and Fifty website about page in the photos, which was written back in 2023 after the initial launch of the website). That was as a Union County Sports Hall of Fame and event center.
A place that could have done/been the following:
•Honored generations of local athletes and aspired future athletes to excel and accomplish bigger and better feats than those before them.
•Expanded beyond the small sports room at the Historical Society that could have showed a bigger meaning of Union County Panther pride, not just in sports, but in showing that even the oldest buildings where memories were made and our tradition mattered and was valued.
•Continued hosting events, gatherings, and celebrations for the community.
•And lastly, but not least importantly, kept the culture and history alive within the very walls where it all happened.
Instead, that opportunity is gone.
We may never know "for certain" if both could have existed, meaning the new fields and the preservation of what stood there before. However, what we do know is this:
A place that once held decades of memories now exists only in memory. And that’s the reality when preservation isn’t part of the conversation.
It’s not always about choosing between progress and history. Sometimes, it’s about having the vision to find a way to honor both.
Because once something like that is gone, it’s gone for good.