07/11/2026
Cruise Price Comparison: Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival (6,164 Cruises Through 2028)
After analyzing more than 6,000 cruises through April 2028, the study found that Royal Caribbean is generally more expensive than Carnival, though the size of the premium varies by ship, port, and season.
Key Findings
Average daily cost (for two passengers, including taxes, fees, and gratuities):
Carnival: $324/day
Royal Caribbean: $414/day
Royal costs about 27% more overall.
7-day cruises:
Carnival average: $2,231
Royal Caribbean average: $3,014
Royal costs about $783 more per cabin (35% higher).
Inside vs. Balcony cabins:
Royal Caribbean inside cabin: $358/day
Carnival balcony cabin: $360/day
A Carnival balcony costs almost the same as a Royal inside room, offering more cabin value for the money.
Newest Ships vs. Older Ships
Newest ships:
Carnival Excel Class: $347/day
Royal Caribbean Icon Class: $643/day
Royal's newest ships carry an 86% premium.
Ships 20+ years old:
Carnival: $340/day
Royal Caribbean: $375/day
The gap shrinks to about 10%, making older Royal ships a more affordable option.
Departure Port Matters
Royal’s premium is highest in Florida:
Miami: Royal costs 51% more
Port Canaveral (Orlando): 40% more
The gap is smaller elsewhere:
Los Angeles: 9% more
Galveston: 13% more
In some ports, Carnival is actually more expensive:
New Orleans
Tampa (11% higher than Royal)
Seasonal Trends
Both lines are most expensive in summer.
Royal’s premium is largest during summer (33% higher than Carnival).
The smallest gap occurs in spring, when Royal averages just 18% more than Carnival.
Bottom Line
Carnival is generally the more budget-friendly option, while Royal Caribbean commands higher prices, especially on its newest ships and Florida departures.
Whether the extra cost is worth it depends on how much you value Royal’s ships, attractions, and onboard experience versus Carnival’s lower fares and better cabin value.
Source: Cruise Fever