05/31/2026
Decisive Battle
During World War II Japan had the concept of a decisive battle. The idea was that this would be the battle that would turn the war in their favor to the point the Allies could not recover. The Japanese would then be able to sue for peace on their own terms.
It is an interesting idea but one, according to them, they never fulfilled. (It will come around to dogs, just hang one.)
I tend to disagree with the thought that this never came about. There were a couple of decisive battles but they simply didn't go the way that the Japanese Navy wanted them to go. Fact of the matter is that there could never really be a decisive battle from the Japanese side.
As I have been reading (okay, I admit it, listening too) a lot of WWII history books recently and I am sick to death of the phrase "Decisive Battle". It feels far more like the person who is waiting for a sign and the sign hits them in the face but it is not the sign they wanted so they keep searching.
I see this so much in day to day life as well as dog training. Handlers are waiting for "that seminar" and it will fix every problem I have ever had. I know it!
Spoiler alert, it doesn't. I mean if you pay attention, listen and practice things will get better for you but that also may have happened had you just done the practice part.
I think I shared this story previously. Penny and I were at runthrus (practice tests) and one of the ladies that was giving the runthrus was there practicing with her dog before everything started. I noted that in between exercises that she could walk over to a table next to the ring and write something down.
I asked her, what are you doing? She said that at the seminar she was at the trainer said to write down everything you do during training with some notes. Then when you get home review the notes. To be effective you have to do this for several weeks. She was currently towards the end of week two and she told me she had seen massive improvement.
"Cool. Can I ask a question?"
"Sure" she said.
I said "how many days in the last two weeks have your practiced?"
"Probably 12 out of 14. " She then started flip through her book counting. "Yes, 12 out of 14."
I then asked "how often did you practice previous to the seminar?"
"Maybe once a week." she said innocently.
I just smiled and said "that's great" and moved on.
The lady needed her decisive battle in order to overcome the issues she was having when in reality just practicing six times a week helped her be more consistent and her dog better understand what she was asking for.
In reality a decisive battle in regular life just looks like a spot where you are rolling the dice and all in on whatever you are trying to achieve. That could be at your annual review where you are going to stand up for yourself or at the car dealership to get the deal you want on the car. They all look pretty much the same and for the most part they are never as big of a deal as you think they are, particularly if you don't win the battle.
Your dogs have all kinds of decisive battles. Whether they can be on the furniture or sleep in bed, if they can pull on the leash on walks or if you really mean "stay" when you say it.
I would argue in many cases your dog's decisive battles are likely more permanent than your own in everyday life. Once a dog figures out how to win the battle they rarely have to retreat and you end up suing for peace in your own house.
I am sure that many reading this are now questioning my connection between all of these things. I mean after all war seems a lot more serious than training your dog or buying a car. That is something I would agree with but the Japanese treated it like it was an everyday thing just like any of these events, it couldn't be a decisive battle if it didn't go their way. Great rule but not one that will work in real life.
Back to the history for a moment.
There were two battles that were really decisive, Guadalcanal and Leyte Gulf. In both cases there was a beatdown by the Allies, granted it was a horribly bloody one for both sides but one changed the course of the war and the second locked in the final result. There are many good books written on the topics and I would be happy to recommend them but for this week, understand where your decisive battles actually lie. Understand what is worth fighting and winning for and what things are just meh moments.
When everything is a decisive battle, nothing is a decisive battle.
Enjoy the week!
-Dave
[Today's photo is of Penny who is a battle all by herself]