06/02/2026
TUESDAY TEACHINGS: Who am I to judge?
I was listening to the BirdNote Daily podcast on my way into work. There was a birder who loves watching American Herring Gulls (these are the ones everyone calls “seagulls” at the beach). The excitement in his voice was adorable as he spoke of these birds. I can’t stand gulls. They are annoying, sneaky, and they constantly try to steal my snacks. The birder said he is so disappointed when people refer to them as “rats with wings”.
I felt immediately guilty. I have called these birds rats with wings. That got me thinking. Who am I to judge which species are superior and which should be disparaged? Why do we as a society generally prefer the soft and cuddly over the rough and scaly? (disclaimer…I love snakes and lizards).
Animals that inconvenience or scare us are often disparaged. Sharks are feared based on a small number of attacks. Horses are loved by many because they are beautiful and majestic. Snakes are vilified in religious texts. Wasps are denigrated and seen as aggressive. Our human judgement is influenced by fear, appearance, or our own opinions rather than the importance of these creatures. I was stung multiple times in a bee swarm as a child. Because of that, I retreat or cower in fear every time I see one. Does that fat little bumblebee deserve my prejudice? No…he is likely just hanging around, pollinating and being cute. Humans also are tip-toeing very close to a dangerous line when we assign our own values to animals because all we have to do is look at history to see how easily this judgement can become cruelty. When humans decide that something is worthless or lowly, destruction can quickly follow. Think of the wolves in Yellowstone. That entire population was wiped out due to human fear of livestock attacks, and we all saw what happened there. Humans do not always have the wisdom or education to judge something’s value accurately.
Animals that we admire possess qualities that we would want for ourselves. Beauty, strength, elegance. This might show that we are incredibly short sighted and egocentric when assigning value. Nature herself shows us that a creature’s worth cannot be measured by beauty or usefulness. Flowers do not deny their pollen to a scary bee while waiting for a beautiful butterfly. Rivers do not hold back their waters from the prehistoric (and often algae covered) snapping turtle to favor, instead, the lovely little fawn gingerly coming forward to get a drink. Trees do not shake the buzzards off their branches while welcoming the eagles. To do so would reveal their arrogance rather than their wisdom.
We all deserve existence and acceptance. We all play an important role in our communities. The world is at her best when everyone, even the misunderstood, are allowed to shine. I will do my best to embrace the herring gulls from now on instead of calling them names. They deserve better.
I am attaching a link to the BirdNote Daily podcast if you are interested in 1-2 minute snippets on the wonders of birds. I find them quite entertaining on my drive in to work.
BirdNote Daily® is a two-minute radio show that combines rich sounds with engaging stories, to illustrate the amazing lives of birds and give listeners a momentary respite from the news of the day.