08/09/2026
If the Lord placed Twelve to guard His Church, what is left in a village when the Church is no longer there, but the habit of seating twelve to watch that there be no iniquity still remains?
The reign of the judges is the political system that replaced the Nephite monarchy (Mosiah to 3 Nephi).
It lasted about 120 years (approx. 91 B.C.–30 A.D.). It wasn't a modern democracy, but a mixed government based on the voice of the people, the law of the fathers, and judges at various levels.📜
1. Why it was established (Mosiah 29)Mosiah proposed this system after his sons chose missionary work over the throne. His reasons:
• A wicked king drags everyone into sin (like King Noah).
• The people must answer for their own sins, not the king for them.
• To avoid succession wars.
• “It is not common that the voice of the people desireth anything contrary to that which is right.”Alma the Younger became the first chief judge and high priest.
🏛️ 2. How it was organized• Lower judges: Handled local cases in every city.
• Higher judges: Intermediate level to review lower courts.
• Chief judge (Governor): Presided over Zarahemla, holding judicial and executive power.
• The Counterweight: If a chief judge was unrighteous, a small council of lower judges could try him according to the voice of the people (Mosiah 29:29).⚔️
3. What they did (According to the record)
• Judged cases like priestcraft (Nehor), anti-faith agendas (Korihor), debts, and rebellion.
• Governed to maintain peace and freedom of worship.
• Collected wages based on their time of service (Alma 11:3).
• Separated offices when needed (like Alma giving up the judgment-seat to focus on preaching).
In total, about 12 men served as chief judge.
🔍 THE HISTORICAL CONNECTION: MESOAMERICA
It is fascinating to see that in the 15th and 16th centuries, Spanish chroniclers described this exact same type of judicial government still operating in Mesoamerican societies:✍️
1. Hernán Cortés (The Marketplace Judges)
"There is in this great square a very fine house, like an audience hall, where ten or twelve persons are always seated, who are judges and resolve all cases and matters that arise in the said market, and order the punishment of offenders... inspecting measures with which they measure what they sell..."
✍️ 2. Fray Motolinia (The 12-Day Council & Fixed Wages)
"In each of those towns there were two judges... The king assigned them suitable lands... for their sustenance... Appeals were made to two other judges who presided over all... Every ten or twelve days, the king held counsel with all the judges... Those twelve judges had twelve other ministers, who were like chief constables..."
✍️ 3. Fray Bernardino de Sahagún (Honesty & The Twelve)
"The rulers... chose prudent and wise judges, honest people educated in the Calmecac... In appeals, there were twelve judges who held jurisdiction over all others... Every twelve days the ruler met with all the judges... They made no distinction between important or common, rich or poor..."(Chambers: Tlacxitlan for criminal, Teccalli for civil, Tecpilcalli for nobility. Chief judges were called tecutlatoque).
"The friars saw about twelve seated.
The Lord, in 3 Nephi, called Twelve.
They are not the same office.
One baptizes and ministers.
The other judges the marketplace and the palace.
I cannot tell you that these judges are a memory of those disciples.
That would be more than I know.
What I can ask you—and this is no longer history, it is faith—is:If a people once sat at the feet of Christ,is everything erased? Or does only the form sometimes remain: the number, the council, the fear of bribery, while the covenant is lost?
Mosiah did not set up twelve. He set up judges who could judge the one at the top.
Christ did set up Twelve!
The Mexicas, a thousand years later, have a council of about twelve.
Three distinct things.
A single question: Who reminds us that the law must stand above the man who applies it?"
"Twelve disciples in the record.
Twelve judges in the chronicles.
I am not proving they are the same.
I am asking if a people can forget the Lordand still seat twelveso that iniquity does not sit upon the judgment-seat.
That, to me, is a question of faith."
Carlos Alemán
Immersive private tours led by a 20-year expert guide