18/08/2026
Refugee claims and thresholds are usually not well understood. Just because you don't like your home country, or there is a risk of ill treatment doesn't mean you can claim refugee status. The examples in the article show this really well, the successful applicants mentioned were successful because although they had dual US / Jordan citizenship it was likely that the US would deport them to Jordan. The threshold for cruel or degrading treatment was assessed with respect to Jordan, not the US.
A US citizen may actually be at risk of various harm / death / prejudice and so on just by living in the US, but there is a presumption that the US authorities will actually (try to) protect against this, so a refugee claim is doomed to fail. Even though in the US many people are actually subject to arbitary death, torture and so on through gun violence, prejudice, unaffordable health care, etc, because this is not actually sanctioned or ignored by the authorities it will not meet the threshold for a refugee status claim.
Government figures show more than 20 Americans have applied for asylum in New Zealand since 2020 - and at least one family was accepted.