The Madison Fire Island Pines

The Madison Fire Island Pines It’s a beautiful space, centrally located but a world away. themadisonfi.com All rooms come with a/c and private baths.

The Madison is recommended by Travel & Leisure as the island’s best accommodations, and has been named by Travel Noire as one of the best gay-owned locales worldwide. Wonderfully chic and completely brand-new, The Madison is different from anything you've ever experienced in this internationally-famous gay community. Stylish and modern, it's a place where flat-screen televisions, high-speed intern

et service and massages by the pool are just the beginning. There's a grand deck, a huge pool, a hot tub and a roof deck with panoramic views of the Pines. And the location is unbelievable: It's sixty seconds from the beach and sixty seconds from the harbor. Fire Island finally has a weekend home as beautiful as the Pines itself.

Book your stay today at www.themadisonfi.com!
03/05/2026

Book your stay today at www.themadisonfi.com!

The Pines’ acclaimed guest house, situated in the heart of the world’s most beautiful gay resort community. It’s an exclusive compound a world away.

Happy new year from The Madison! Our big summer weeks are filling up fast - we recommend you book your stay soon. Our ex...
01/04/2026

Happy new year from The Madison! Our big summer weeks are filling up fast - we recommend you book your stay soon. Our extensive upgrades last year touched every corner of the property - from gardens to sun decks to bedrooms to bathrooms - and garnered an overwhelming positive response from our guests. Come see for yourself this summer why there’s nothing on Fire Island like The Madison.

The Pines’ acclaimed guest house, situated in the heart of the world’s most beautiful gay resort community. It’s an exclusive compound a world away.

Bowen Yang’s big send-off on SNL brings back memories of his time at The Madison. He and the cast of “Fire Island” spent...
12/22/2025

Bowen Yang’s big send-off on SNL brings back memories of his time at The Madison. He and the cast of “Fire Island” spent two weeks with us while shooting the movie in 2021 (the guy on the left is our owner Andrew Kirtzman). We wish him well on his road to future stardom.

Thank you to the cast of “Fire Island” for making The Madison your home this month - we loved having you!

Pictured: Madison owner Andrew Kirtzman, Andrew Ahn, Tomas Matos, James Scully, Matt Rogers & Bowen Yang (on his way to the Emmy’s!)

Happy Halloween Party Weekend! The Madison still has room availabilites this weekend - check out our website. We are ope...
10/16/2025

Happy Halloween Party Weekend! The Madison still has room availabilites this weekend - check out our website. We are open Fridays-Mondays through the end of October!

The Pines’ acclaimed guest house, situated in the heart of the world’s most beautiful gay resort community. It’s an exclusive compound a world away.

The Madison got 20 reviews on AirBnB this season. Here are all of them. Come stay with us and see what our guests are ta...
10/05/2025

The Madison got 20 reviews on AirBnB this season. Here are all of them.
Come stay with us and see what our guests are talking about. We’re open through the end of October.

The sunlight is at its most romantic this time of year in the Pines. Book your stay today and discover why September and...
09/16/2025

The sunlight is at its most romantic this time of year in the Pines. Book your stay today and discover why September and October are the most beautiful months of the year here. The Madison is open for another six weeks - stay with us through October 27th and discover the magic for yourself.

The Pines’ acclaimed guest house, situated in the heart of the world’s most beautiful gay resort community. It’s an exclusive compound a world away.

08/08/2025
08/08/2025

Back’s inked.
Booty’s branded.
And yes, it’s just as hot as it looks. 🔥👀
📸:

The first thing you encounter when entering The Madison is our beautiful new front garden. Just one of our many upgrades...
05/29/2025

The first thing you encounter when entering The Madison is our beautiful new front garden. Just one of our many upgrades this season.

Take a bow this Memorial Day weekend, Mike Cruz! Our general manager is the man who keeps The Madison looking beautiful ...
05/24/2025

Take a bow this Memorial Day weekend, Mike Cruz! Our general manager is the man who keeps The Madison looking beautiful and running like a well-oiled machine. Wildly talented and fiercely dedicated, he’s a huge part of why we’ve been so successful for 18 years. He’s been in charge for more than a decade in that time, and we’re so lucky to have him.

Happy Memorial Day weekend from The Madison! We’re all spiffed up for another season. Come stay with us and see all that...
05/23/2025

Happy Memorial Day weekend from The Madison! We’re all spiffed up for another season. Come stay with us and see all that’s new here this summer. We’re feeling pretty glamorous.

Address

22 Atlantic Walk
Fire Island, NY
11782

Telephone

(631)5976061

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Madison Fire Island Pines posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share