Shafer Shores Too, LLC

Shafer Shores Too, LLC Shafer Shores Too, LLC offers two beautiful connecting cottages along Shafer Lake that are available for rent.

Each cottage has a screened in porch with a stunning lake front view, and both include the following:

* 2 bedroom: 1 with a queen size bed & 1 with 2 twin beds ( linen included )
* sofa sleeper
* Kitchen ( including: microwave, toaster, coffee pot, blender, kitchen utencils )
* Cable TV in each room
* Stereo / CD player
* Gas grill with grilling utencils
* Fire pit
* Boat dock in front of the co

ttage

*** Boat launch available 1/2 mile, across from Tall Timbers Marina***

NOT INCLUDED: Paper products , bath towels, & kitchen towels. CHECK-IN : 3:00 PM CHECK-OUT : 11:00 AM

Rental Pricing:


May & June $ 825 / Week

July, August, & September $ 925 / Week


Payment:

Please make checks to: SHAFER SHORES TOO, LLC

Remit payment to :

Cynthia Bertagnolli
1332 MacArthur Blvd
Munster, IN 46321



To check for availability please click the Events tab to show which weeks are already booked.

04/01/2026

Summer nights just got even better at Indiana Beach

Our 2026 Fireworks Schedule is officially LIVE!

Watch the sky come alive from the boardwalk as we light up the lake all summer long. There’s nothing like fireworks over the water at Indiana Beach.

✨ Make it a night to remember with rides, food, and a front-row seat to the show

👉 See the full schedule and plan your visit:
https://www.indianabeach.com/fireworks

Last-minute cancellations!  vacancies available from  July 12 to the 19th dmMe
07/08/2025

Last-minute cancellations!  vacancies available from  July 12 to the 19th dm
Me

Last minute cancellation at Shafer shores TOO  on LAKE SHAFER  in Monticello, Indiana!!!JULY 12-19!219-218-5454!!!! ...
07/03/2025

Last minute cancellation at Shafer shores TOO  on LAKE SHAFER  in Monticello, Indiana!!!JULY 12-19!
219-218-5454!!!! Year round cottages two bedrooms one queen 2 twins living room has pullout couch right on the water fully stocked with anything you need in the kitchen a mile down the road from the entrance of Indiana Beach but very quiet you cannot hear the Indiana beach noise!

06/29/2024

Last-minute cancellation at Shafer Shores for the week of July 13 through the 20th. Call 219-218-5454 if interested.

07/30/2023
07/20/2023

It’s not easy to satisfy everyone when it comes to apparel, especially when choosing one as a gift - unless you opt for our personalized apparel. A personalized shirt is a perfect gift for all occasions and makes your loved one feel even more special.PRODUCT DETAILS: Brand: Gildan Printed in US wi...

06/20/2023

Rare cancellation for a4 of July week July 1-8 and July 15 to the 22nd book now while you can

Address

4587 & 4585 N W Shafer Drive
Monticello, IN
47960

Telephone

+12198381577

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shafer Shores Too, LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Shafer Shores Too, LLC:

Shortcuts

Share

Category