05/14/2026
🍦 White County Foodie Adventures: A Sweet Monticello Tradition
This week, our adventure takes us to Monticello for a stop that’s as sweet as it gets: An Extra Scoop.
An Extra Scoop became part of owner Felicity David’s journey in 2022, shortly after graduating high school, when she stepped into ownership and turned a big opportunity into a true passion. What started as a leap forward quickly grew into something meaningful, a place designed for the community to gather, slow down, and enjoy a little joy in every visit.
The heart of An Extra Scoop is simple: ice cream should be fun, generous, and memorable. That shows up in every detail, from rotating flavors to creative, over-the-top treats that keep customers coming back to see what’s new. And yes, the extra scoop is very real, and always worth it.
One of the most rewarding parts of the shop has been watching it become part of people’s routines and memories. Families stop in to celebrate small wins, friends catch up over cones and cups, and regulars are always greeted like familiar faces. It’s a space built to feel welcoming, creative, and just a little different from the ordinary ice cream stop.
If you’re in Monticello, it’s more than worth a visit, it’s a place made for sweet moments and second scoops.
📍 230 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960
Stay tuned! More delicious stops on our White County Foodie Adventures are coming soon. Join us next week as we head to our next stop! 👀🍨