05/26/2026
I was meeting my daughter for lunch and found out about the new location for Utopia Bagels. Since it's a block north of an existing Ess-a-Bagel location, we decided to do a taste test. For several years, I've considered these 2 companies the best bagel makers in NYC, so to have 2 locations so close was an opportunity I couldn't pass on. We started at the Ess-a-Bagel on 3rd Avenue between East 50th and 51st Streets. It was 3 pm, so the place was pretty empty. We grabbed 1/2 dozen bagels for my daughter to take home and ordered a tuna sandwich on an onion bagel. It was terrific! Overflowing with tuna, not too mayo-ey, with some lettuce on it to give it the idea of being healthy. The bagel itself was huge with a crunch to it, but soft on the inside. The same bagel I've touted as NYC's best for years.
We then headed to Utopia's new location on 3rd Avenue and East 52nd Street. A beautiful, shiny spot that I can imagine will soon be packed on weekdays for both breakfast and lunch. It was pretty empty when we got there and ordered another 1/2 dozen bagels to go. After the huge bagel sandwich at Ess-A, we opted for a garlic bagel with scallion cream cheese. Here, the star was the delectable cream cheese. Yes, the bagel was good, but not great. definitely not up to the quality of the Ess-A bagel we had just had, but that cream cheese was terrific!!
So, you ask, which shop was the winner, which place has the best bagels in NYC? The answer was clear, it was Ess-a-Bagel, but to be fair, if I was rushing to work or wanting to grab something for lunch, I could go with either of these wonderful shops and know I'm having a bagel at the very top of New York's bagels. A bagel worthy of New York City.