09/21/2026
MORE FISHING DAYS SOUND GREAT. BUT WHO IS COUNTING THE FISH?
Every recreational fisherman wants more opportunity. So do we.
We want accurate data, reasonable regulations, healthy artificial reefs, fewer fish lost to sharks and a federal government that understands what fishing means to families and coastal communities.
That is why the new executive order on saltwater recreational fishing is getting so much applause.
Boat manufacturers, tackle companies and fishing-rights organizations are celebrating better access, stronger state control and greater consideration of recreational fishing’s economic value.
But before we join the celebration, fishermen should ask one simple question:
Will this produce healthier fish stocks, or just longer seasons?
The executive order directs NOAA to reconsider the guidelines for National Standard 1, which governs optimum yield and preventing overfishing, and National Standard 2, which requires management to use the best scientific information available.
It also opens the door for state recreational estimates to replace federal estimates under certain conditions.
State data may be better. Federal recreational data certainly have problems. But replacing one flawed system with five different state systems does not automatically give us the truth.
There is also a difference between precision and accuracy. A survey can repeatedly produce a very precise number while still missing anglers, trips or fishing effort. Getting the same wrong answer several times does not make it right.
The states also have an unavoidable conflict. They set their fishing seasons, receive the political and economic benefit of longer seasons, and then estimate whether their anglers stayed within the allocation.
That is like letting each football team choose the referees, keep the scoreboard and decide afterward whether the winning touchdown counted.
This is where the fishing-rights message usually becomes thin.
We hear about access, opportunity, jobs, sales and economic impact. Those things matter. But where are the equally specific promises about independent validation, preventing overfishing, paying back quota overages and protecting fish abundance?
More access sells boats, motors, fuel, tackle and memberships. Healthy fisheries create those same benefits over the long term, but conservation sometimes requires saying no in the short term.
That is the part fishermen are rarely told.
Industry advocacy groups have every right to represent their members and businesses. But they are advocates, not independent scientific referees. Their policy recommendations should be supported by evidence, not accepted because they arrive in attractive bullet points labeled “angler access.”
Before any state data replace the federal system, fishermen should demand five protections:
1. Independent scientific review of every state program.
2. One calibrated measuring system so a pound of fish means the same thing across the Gulf.
3. Survey methods selected before the season, not changed after an overage appears.
4. Full accountability and real paybacks when allocations are exceeded.
5. No weakening of the Magnuson-Stevens Act’s requirement to prevent overfishing.
Fishing rights without fishing responsibility are not conservation. They are liquidation.
We should improve bad federal data. We should remove regulations that accomplish nothing. We should build habitat and give fishermen a meaningful voice.
But we should never confuse selling more access today with protecting fishing for tomorrow.
The families fishing with us this year deserve a good opportunity. Their children deserve that same opportunity twenty years from now.
Read the executive order for yourself, then ask the question that every press release should have answered:
How, specifically, will this leave us with healthier fish stocks?
By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, it is hereby ordered: Section 1. Purpose and Every child deserves a safe and nurturing home where they can learn, grow, and reach their full potential. Adoption makes that possible by opening...
