09/04/2026
Enjoy a scenic and historic dinner at this week's featured spot: Old Mill Inn in Mattituck.
Tucked at the end of West Mill Road, where Mattituck Creek runs out toward the Long Island Sound, this unique spot has been standing since the early 1820s. It started as a tidal grist mill built by a farmer home from the War of 1812, ground grain until 1902, then became a tavern. During Prohibition it ran as a speakeasy with jazz bands most nights. The original drive shaft is still there at the bar, and guests have been signing the beams for over a century.
The view is just one reason to go! Boats slide past the deck, the water goes gold as the light drops, and dinner turns into a into relaxation and great food.
π 5775 West Mill Rd, Mattituck, NY