The Honest Sutler

Directions

The Honest Sutler The Honest Sutler offers historically accurate Civil War era clothing. Please feel free to contact any one of us with any questions or needs!

-Nathan Kalvitis, Tyler Grecco, Jeorge Galutia, and Conor Sullivan are dedicated living historians who offer accurate reproductions of Civil War era clothing and equipment at affordable prices. Our mission is to uniform living historians with quality reproductions and to give the customer a honest, friendly, and pleasant experience. We look forward to doing business with you!
-The "Honest Sutler" name is in no way an offense to other reenacting sutlers, but rather a play on the period view of the dishonest, scheming military sutler.

***Refund Policy: All products are custom made, we do not offer refunds on any order once payment has been processed.***

A beautiful pair of W.B. Button contract mounted trousers, along with a tan contract shirt. — These trousers feature bro...
10/07/2026

A beautiful pair of W.B. Button contract mounted trousers, along with a tan contract shirt. — These trousers feature broadcloth stripes which denote the rank of Sergeant. Branch stripes of all color and rank commonly extended up the pocket and ended at the waistband. However, there are extant examples ending at the bottom or even middle of the pocket. I felt it looked neat and made sense to shorten these stripes, which already featured piecing. I love the way these turned out.

A small group buy for federal trousers — For these being the most basic ‘budget’ repro trouser in my arsenal, I sure do ...
10/02/2026

A small group buy for federal trousers — For these being the most basic ‘budget’ repro trouser in my arsenal, I sure do enjoy “mass producing” them.

Simple details like getting a little bit of bleed on a sizing dot, an upside down inspectors stamp or that nice little mess of stitches finishing the cuff vent always give something otherwise ordinary the right look.

A simple officers sack coat heading to, you guessed it, Franklin.
09/18/2026

A simple officers sack coat heading to, you guessed it, Franklin.

Tart’s “Enbrowned Jean” frock coat. Another Garment heading to Franklin!
09/16/2026

Tart’s “Enbrowned Jean” frock coat. Another Garment heading to Franklin!

A Columbus depot jacket ready for Franklin!
09/09/2026

A Columbus depot jacket ready for Franklin!

One of many in my next run of tan contract shirts! Send me a message if you are interested in having one made while this...
09/04/2026

One of many in my next run of tan contract shirts! Send me a message if you are interested in having one made while this awesome flannel is in stock.

Great side profile on this ‘size 1’ Schuylkill Arsenal jacket. Part of a small run I recently finished up. Thank you to ...
09/02/2026

Great side profile on this ‘size 1’ Schuylkill Arsenal jacket. Part of a small run I recently finished up. Thank you to those who waited patiently for the restock on 1/2 inch eagle buttons for these projects.

More W.B. Button mounted trousers and a pair of custom dark blue federal trousers finished up last week. Send me a messa...
08/31/2026

More W.B. Button mounted trousers and a pair of custom dark blue federal trousers finished up last week. Send me a message if you’re interested in having a pair of federal trousers made!

A Cavalry Sergeants mounted service jacket, part of a full suit currently in the works.
08/21/2026

A Cavalry Sergeants mounted service jacket, part of a full suit currently in the works.

A small batch of W.B. Button mounted trousers, made using beautiful W&W federal kersey. More mounted gear coming!
08/19/2026

A small batch of W.B. Button mounted trousers, made using beautiful W&W federal kersey. More mounted gear coming!

Address

Rochester, NY
13032

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Honest Sutler posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share