The Honest Sutler

The Honest Sutler The Honest Sutler offers Civil War era clothing made with historical accuracy in mind. Please feel free to contact any one of us with any questions or needs!

-Nathan Kalvitis, Tyler Grecco, Jeorge Galutia, and Conor Sullivan are dedicated living historians who offer accurate reproductions of Civil War era clothing and equipment at affordable prices. Our mission is to uniform living historians with quality reproductions and to give the customer a honest, friendly, and pleasant experience. We look forward to doing business with you!
-The "Honest Sutler"

name is in no way an offense to other reenacting sutlers, but rather a play on the period view of the dishonest, scheming military sutler.

***Refund Policy: All products are custom made, we do not offer refunds on any order once payment has been processed.***

One of many in my next run of tan contract shirts! Send me a message if you are interested in having one made while this...
09/04/2026

One of many in my next run of tan contract shirts! Send me a message if you are interested in having one made while this awesome flannel is in stock.

Great side profile on this ‘size 1’ Schuylkill Arsenal jacket. Part of a small run I recently finished up. Thank you to ...
09/02/2026

Great side profile on this ‘size 1’ Schuylkill Arsenal jacket. Part of a small run I recently finished up. Thank you to those who waited patiently for the restock on 1/2 inch eagle buttons for these projects.

More W.B. Button mounted trousers and a pair of custom dark blue federal trousers finished up last week. Send me a messa...
08/31/2026

More W.B. Button mounted trousers and a pair of custom dark blue federal trousers finished up last week. Send me a message if you’re interested in having a pair of federal trousers made!

A Cavalry Sergeants mounted service jacket, part of a full suit currently in the works.
08/21/2026

A Cavalry Sergeants mounted service jacket, part of a full suit currently in the works.

A small batch of W.B. Button mounted trousers, made using beautiful W&W federal kersey. More mounted gear coming!
08/19/2026

A small batch of W.B. Button mounted trousers, made using beautiful W&W federal kersey. More mounted gear coming!

A few more state jackets out the door! I am loving the look and feel of these lightweight unstructured roundabouts.
08/14/2026

A few more state jackets out the door! I am loving the look and feel of these lightweight unstructured roundabouts.

Overcoats made using B&B Tarts’ fantastic federal sky blue kersey always look just right to me. This mounted example is ...
07/31/2026

Overcoats made using B&B Tarts’ fantastic federal sky blue kersey always look just right to me. This mounted example is also lined with Tart fatigue blouse flannel.

Wanted to take a moment to plug these tan contract shirts. I still have a ton of this fabric which is the best I have e...
07/17/2026

Wanted to take a moment to plug these tan contract shirts. I still have a ton of this fabric which is the best I have ever found/used for these. Great mixed color, light weight flannel. Send me a message if you are interested! - Nathan

Heading to Poland! A Richmond style jacket, made from Tart ‘English Army Cloth’ and trimmed with 2nd Lieutenants insigni...
07/15/2026

Heading to Poland!

A Richmond style jacket, made from Tart ‘English Army Cloth’ and trimmed with 2nd Lieutenants insignia. If you want one of these made, just forget it!

Kidding of course, but I will only accept a small number as they do take some time.

FOR SALE & READY TO SHIP! First come, first served. I have a beautifully shaped Richmond Depot type 1, up for grabs! Han...
07/14/2026

FOR SALE & READY TO SHIP!

First come, first served. I have a beautifully shaped Richmond Depot type 1, up for grabs! Hand finished, made from Tart ‘Sumac on Brown’ jeans, and drafted directly from a mid 19th century manual. This curvy jacket will fit a size 40 snugly, be ideal for a size 38, and will look good on a 36 chest. Asking $275.00. Send me a message!

You could also rip the tape off for a great looking RD2. (no sun fading)

Address

Rochester, NY
13032

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Honest Sutler posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share