09/30/2026
Spotlight: Martha Corey
This September, we remember the 9 innocent people who lost their lives during the final month of ex*****ons in the Salem Witch Trials. Today, we remember Martha Corey.
Martha Corey was not an obvious target. She was a full member of the church, considered pious, and by 1692 had worked hard to build a respectable life in Salem Village. That is part of what made her accusation so important. Up to that point, many of those accused had lived on the margins of society. Martha did not. Once the accusations reached a woman like her, it became clear that no amount of respectability, church membership, or social standing could guarantee safety.
Martha's early life is difficult to reconstruct with certainty. She was born somewhere in New England, but her exact birth date and even some details of her parentage remain unclear. Before her marriage to Giles Corey, she had already lived through a complicated personal history. She had a son, Benoni, born outside of marriage, something that carried enormous social stigma in Puritan New England. She later married Henry Rich and had another son, Thomas. After Henry's death, Martha married the wealthy Salem Village farmer Giles Corey in 1690.
As discussed on the 19th, Giles had a difficult reputation of his own. He had been involved in numerous legal disputes and, most seriously, had been prosecuted after severely beating his farm worker Jacob Goodale, who later died. Martha and Giles were both people with complicated pasts, but by the early 1690s they had become members of the church and were living together on Giles's farm in Salem Farms, modern day Peabody, MA.
When the witchcraft accusations began in early 1692, Martha was openly skeptical. Giles attended the first examinations, but Martha apparently believed the proceedings were foolish and even tried to prevent him from going to one by removing or hiding his saddle. Whether she was simply arguing with her husband or actively protesting the trials, people noticed, and soon the accusations turned toward her.
Ann Putnam Jr. claimed Martha's specter had attacked her. Before any formal examination, Edward Putnam and Ezekiel Cheever went to speak with Martha. They first stopped at the Putnam house, intending to ask Ann what clothing Martha's specter had been wearing so they could compare it to what Martha actually had on. Ann claimed Martha's specter had blinded her and prevented her from seeing. When the men reached Martha's home, she surprised them by already knowing why they had come. “I know what ye are coming for,” she reportedly told them. “Ye are come to talk with me about being a witch.” Then she asked whether Ann had told them what clothes she was wearing.
To Putnam and Cheever, the question was deeply suspicious. How could Martha know what they intended to ask? Martha later explained that she had heard people discussing how the afflicted supposedly identified the clothing worn by the specters they saw. But in the atmosphere of 1692, an ordinary explanation was no longer enough.
A warrant was issued for Martha's arrest on March 19. Because it could not be served on Sunday, Martha remained free through March 20 and went to church. Despite knowing that people were calling her a witch and that an arrest warrant was waiting for her, Martha dressed for worship and took her place in the Salem Village meetinghouse as a full member of the congregation. During the service, the afflicted began crying out. Abigail Williams claimed she could see Martha sitting on a beam and nursing a yellow bird between her fingers.
The following day, Martha was arrested and brought back to that same meetinghouse, this time as a prisoner. Her examination quickly became chaotic. The afflicted girls mimicked her movements, fell into fits when she turned her head, claimed to see yellow birds around her, and said that an invisible man was whispering into her ear. John Hathorne repeatedly questioned Martha about how she had known Edward Putnam and Ezekiel Cheever were coming to speak with her.
Martha refused to give him the answers he wanted. When one of the afflicted claimed a man was whispering to her, Hathorne asked Martha what he had said. Martha replied, “We must not believe all that these distracted children say.” Throughout the examination, she denied having anything to do with witchcraft. She laughed at some of the accusations and asked to be allowed to pray. Most importantly, she repeatedly identified herself as something entirely incompatible with the crime being alleged against her: “I am an innocent person. I never had to do with witchcraft since I was born. I am a gospel woman.” The afflicted girls immediately mocked her, calling her a “gospel witch.” Even her faith was turned against her.
The situation became more complicated because of Giles. Early in the proceedings, he had made statements that appeared to support suspicions against his wife. He described strange illnesses involving an ox and a cat, said Martha had criticized the way he prayed, and told others that he knew things that could “fix her business.” Whether Giles actually believed Martha was guilty, was simply complaining about his wife, or was swept up in the fear of the moment is impossible to know. But when Giles himself was accused and arrested in April, his attitude toward the court changed. He stopped cooperating and refused to provide the damaging testimony the magistrates wanted from him. For details on Giles, go to Sept 19th.
By then, both husband and wife were imprisoned. Martha remained in jail for months before her trial. In September, she was convicted of witchcraft and sentenced to death. Then the church turned against her too. On September 11, the Salem Village church voted to excommunicate Martha. Reverend Samuel Parris later visited her in jail to formally pronounce the sentence. His own record describes Martha as refusing to accept the judgment and continuing to defend herself. She had spent years becoming what she proudly called a “gospel woman,” and now, days before her death, the church stripped that identity from her.
On the way to gallows hill, Robert Calef later wrote that the cart carrying the condemned briefly became stuck on the way to the ex*****on site. Even this ordinary delay was interpreted as supernatural, with people claiming the Devil was preventing the cart from moving.
While at the gallows, Martha continued to proclaim her innocence. Calef wrote that she ended her life with “an eminent prayer upon the ladder.” She had been accused in part because people believed a true witch could not possess genuine Christian faith, yet Martha Corey went to her death praying.
Like most of the others, her remains have never been identified. There is something especially tragic about the final days of Martha and Giles Corey. Whatever their marriage had been like, whatever arguments they had shared, and whatever Giles had initially believed about the accusations against his wife, the trials ultimately consumed them both. Giles died beneath stones on September 19. Martha was hanged 3 days later. They were the only married couple both put to death during the Salem Witch Trials.
But Martha's story did not end with the rope. In 1703, the Salem Village church formally reversed her excommunication. The church record admitted that during those “dark” days, they had acted without sufficient grounds and had wrongly condemned her. They specifically asked that the sentence be removed so that the shame attached to Martha's name would not continue through future generations.
In 1711, Massachusetts formally reversed the convictions of both Martha and Giles Corey. Today, memorial stones honoring the couple stand near Crystal Lake in Peabody, on land once connected to Giles's farm. Martha's name is also carved at the Salem Witch Trials Memorial and at Proctor's Ledge.
Martha Corey entered the Salem Witch Trials believing the accusations were foolish. She questioned them, mocked them, and refused to pretend that invisible birds, spectral attacks, and the movements of frightened young people were proof of witchcraft. Then the same system she doubted came for her. She lost her freedom, her church, her husband, and finally her life, but she never surrendered the thing she had insisted upon from the beginning: “I am an innocent person.”
She was.
And with Martha Corey, we close our September Spotlights.