10/29/2026
For two or three years, a mysterious white deer roamed the woods of Johnson County. And then along came Joseph Young with a r***e named “Old Crate.”
According to local historian David Demaree Banta, the unusual deer had been roaming the western and southwestern parts of the county, becoming increasingly wary of hunters.
Joseph Young, an early settler in the Nineveh area, carried a powerful, long-range r***e he called “Old Crate.”
When Young finally encountered the elusive white deer, he brought it down with a shot from a considerable distance.
Apparently, Old Crate lived up to its name.
It's a small detail from Johnson County's early history, but one that makes you wonder what other stories have disappeared along with the forests these settlers once hunted.
And here's something worth noting: White deer aren't necessarily albino. Some have a genetic condition called leucism, which reduces pigmentation without producing the characteristic pink eyes of albinism. We don't know which was the case with Young's deer.
Have you ever seen a white deer in Indiana?
Franklin by Foot | Every block has a backstory.
Source: David Demaree Banta, A Historical Sketch of Johnson County, Indiana, p. 161.